A car enthusiast forum based in the Philippines with over two decades of intelligent discussions about cars, driving, in-car entertainment, motorsports, off-roading, and motoring life.

News:

Welcome to the AutoIndustriya.com Car Discussion Forums!

Main Menu

Fully Synthetic every 3 months or Multigrade every month?

Started by The Jordan, March 14, 2010, 06:57:19 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

The Jordan

Fully Synthetic every 3 months or Multigrade every month?

Which is better? practically costs the same. 2001 engine.

same 20w40
The real question is.. when you turn your car on, does it return the favor?


kimdabalus

holy crap! what was that? :D

bluestar

why change oil so often? pwede siguro every 6months for multigrade/fully synthetic. depends on how much mileage you put on your car.
   bluestar   

tip_tipid

are you averaging 150 KM per day? so you need to change oil that often?  :surprised:

The Jordan

What i meant is diba normally 3monthsm or 3,000km ang average change oil?

What i'm asking is if changing it every month with cheap mineral oil is better than changing it at 3,000km and/or 3months with an expensive fully synthetic better?
The real question is.. when you turn your car on, does it return the favor?


nikko_m

how cheap is your miniral oil?baka naman single grade na mineral oil,but if multi grade naman dun na ako sa change oil every month.

tip_tipid

for the local Philippines environment,  non-synthetic oil, we do it normally every 5,000 km or every 6 months, whichever comes first. For the synthetic oil, change oil every 10,000 km.
Anyway, are you referring to Philippines condition or Europe & Middle East?

The Jordan

Let's say high detergent MO40 or Multigrade na 40w compared sa Royal purple 20w40.

I usually change my Royal Purple after 3-4months eh i figured na same price lang siya pag 3x change oil na multigrade.
The real question is.. when you turn your car on, does it return the favor?


bluestar

MO40 is just a single grade oil and doesn't offers much protection for your engine. Pang taxi lang ang gumagamit ng MO40...nasa 110pesos lang ata per liter yan.

IMO, you're better off with royal purple and change every 4 months. You can try other viscosities like 10w-40, 10w-30, 5w-30...these are lighter oils.
   bluestar   

speedyfix

RP has no 20w40 viscosity. either way is fine but there's more waste with the mineral route.
Migs - 09175347636
Shop - 7226117

www.speedyfixph.com

308 P. Guevarra corner Seaview St San Juan

Accord GTR

Changing your oil once-a-month is too much unless you are doing 20,000 kms or more, or you race or join trackdays. 

You should follow the manufacturer's recommended oil viscosity and service interval or half (if they recommend once a year, do it every 6 months) of it if you really want your engine to last long. 

I think 3x/month is fine and using mineral oil with the manufacturer's recommended viscosity. 

Like for Honda, using the dealer's oil is good enough.  If you wanna spend more for synthetic, that's really up to your budget.

Me, I check the oil and if its dark and dirty, I change it.  Usually, if you have an open air filter, it will dirty your oil faster.  Also if you modify your engine or its turbo, I notice the oil gets dirty quicker too.  Dirty gas will also dirty your oil quicker.


There is no dishonor in losing the race. There is

Leo C.

Quote from: The Jordan on March 14, 2010, 06:57:19 PM
Fully Synthetic every 3 months or Multigrade every month?

Which is better? practically costs the same. 2001 engine.

same 20w40

Meron be talaga Full Synthetics? We have already established the fact that synthetic oils are preferred by many motorists than conventional mineral oils. We are also aware of the benefits derived in using synthetic oils. But our next question is: Which Synthetic Oil Should I Use? Is one brand better than the other? What should I look for in buying synthetic oils?
This is a tricky question. There really is not much of an industry standard definition when it comes to synthetic oil, so be careful. The term synthetic has become more generic these days and has more to do with oil quality than it does with the actual oil itself.
Many, if not all synthetic brands have "FULL SYNTHETIC" or "100% SYNTHETIC" or "ALL SYNTHETIC" written on the label but how are you certain that you are buying the right stuff?   It's just like saying "100% Coffee". Yes it is, but is it Arabica, Excelsa or Robusta? Or "100% PURE BEEF"... Carabeef or Cow's beef? Or a blend of the two?

Grades of Oil.
Motor oils are derived from base stocks. That is, a generic oil base is modified with additives to produce a lubricant with the desired properties. A base stock oil with no additives would not perform very well at all. Base stocks are classified by the American Petroleum Institute (API) and fall into one of five categories.
·   Group I and II - these are mineral oils derived from crude oil. (That's basic. No comment about that.)

·   Group III - this is a highly refined mineral oil made through a process called hydrocracking. In North America this group is considered a     synthetic oil, for marketing purposes. (Hmm. . . quite confusing...... A mineral oil considered as synthetic oil?)

·   Group IV - these are true synthetic oils, known as Polyalphaolefin (PAO).

·   Group V - these are synthetic stocks other than PAO's and include esters and other compounds. (Other compounds???)

Synthetic Base Oils
Currently, there are three main fluids used for synthetic base oil in engine oils:
-  Polyalphaolefins (PAO)
-  Synthetic Esters (Group V)
-  Hydroprocessed Mineral Oil (Remember Group III?)
If you want a true high performance synthetic, you probably want an oil which uses PAO base oil. PAO is the classic synthetic fluid used to make synthetic engine oil and it has excellent low and high temperature properties. The easiest way to verify the use of PAO is to ask the manufacturer for the pour point of their oil. If the pour point is –54°C or lower, then you've got a PAO based synthetic oil. Some oils have "PAO" or "polyalfaolefins"  written on the label.
Over the past 25+ years, PAO has been the most popular fluid used for synthetic engine oil. PAO is a pure chemically engineered substance. It starts by chemically reacting pure ethylene (an invisible, explosive gas) into a molecule known as decene (a clear, thin liquid). The decene molecules are then reacted to form a pure molecule known as Polyalphaolefin (PAO). The PAO molecules can be small or large depending on how much decene is reacted. The bigger the PAO molecule, the more viscous it becomes. In the end, you have a pure chemical substance with very strong molecular bonds that resists physical and chemical breakdown. (Now that is synthetic!!!)

PAO is usually combined with a small amount of synthetic ester to provide even greater high temperature durability and improved chemical solubility. Synthetic esters are manufactured by reacting an acid and an alcohol. The reaction products are water and ester. Esters are very stable at extremely high temperatures and are used almost exclusively in jet engines. Unfortunately, full ester engine oils do not work well in automobile engines due to lower operating temperatures and exposure to moisture. If ester is exposed to high moisture at moderate temperatures, it tends to react back into the acid and alcohol. You can imagine what acid in your crankcase would do to your engine.

Hydroprocessed Mineral Oil is a more recent fluid used for synthetic engine oil. This fluid is actually just conventional oil, which has been processed to remove more of the small and large molecules. In the end, the fluid is much more stable at high temperatures and provides good service for high temperature engine operation. Unfortunately, it provides little or no improvement for low temperature operation since it still contains wax. Since this fluid provides good performance at a lower cost than PAO/Ester formulations, it has found its way into the marketplace as synthetic oil. It is somewhat questionable how synthetic this fluid is. (Careful Careful)     (Tsismis.) There are claims that Mobil 1 is not using PAO base oils. (Hehe).

My final recommendation is again . . . careful, careful.

Late in 1997, Castrol changed the formula of its Syntec "full synthetic motor oil", eliminating the polyalphaolefin (PAO) base stock (that's the "synthetic" part, which makes up about 70% by volume of what's in the bottle) and replacing it with a "hydroisomerized" petroleum base stock.